Ethiopia
Operating Hours
Monday to Friday: 9 AM - 6 PM
next page course

Substantive and Procedural law

It is also possible to classify law as substantive and procedural law. Substantive law determines the rights and obligations of persons. If a law grants aright or imposes an obligation up on an individual we call such law as a substantive law. These laws include contract law, business law and family law. Substantive law is about the creation of law and obligation.However procedural law governs the method by which legal rights ascertained by the substantive laws are enforced. After you ascertained the existence of a right you may want to enforce it. The steps that you must go through in order to ascertain your right are governed by procedural law.Federal and State lawsEthiopia is a federal government. In a federal government power is shared between the federal government and member states. The FDRE constitution allocates law making power between the federal and state governments. And the laws which are enacted by the federal government in accordance with its constitutional power are called federal laws while those laws which are legislated by the states are called state laws.Domestic and International LawThis classification is based up on the jurisdiction of the countries. Laws which are enacted by a given state legislature to be applicable with in the territory of that state are called domestic law. Their application is limited to the territory of the given state. For instance, Ethiopian laws such as employment and tax laws are domestic by nature and apply only within Ethiopia. The rules of business law that we discuss the subsequent chapters are domestic laws and are applicable within Ethiopian territory.Nevertheless, international law regulates the actions of two or more international actors. The main international actors are states. Others are like international organizations like UN (United Nation), regional organization like AU (African Union), and other International NGOs and Multi-National Corporations. Unlike domestic laws, the application of international laws is not limited within one country. International law applies up on these actors across borders.Dispute resolution MechanismWhat kind of depute resolution mechanisms have ever you used? Do you think it is wise to file every case to a court to get a judgment? What are the advantages and disadvantages of court litigation and ADR?In our daily life disputes arises. Like wise in the business world disagreements are inevitably occur. The partner who you have been working with may break a contract; a friend that you lend money my refuse to pay back; the insurance company may refuse to pay compensation when the damage is occurred up on the insured property; you may suffer a loss due to the other party fault. In all this cases deputes arise.The best way, of course, of resolving a dispute is to make sure it does not happen in the first place. Carefully thought out commercial deals and well drafted legal documentation as well as good working commercial relationships can minimize the risk of disputes. However, not all circumstances can be foreseen and, in any event, many disputes arise more out of commercial necessity (delay, cash flow problems, confusion) rather than out of real matters of legal disagreement.In such cases there are two ways of solving a dispute: judicial settlement Sof dispute (Court litigation) and extrajudicial settlement of dispute, or Alternative Dispute Resolution Mechanisms (ADR). Lets see them in detail.Judicial Settlement of Disputes(Court litigation)A controversy before a court or a "lawsuit" is commonly referred to as litigation. If it is not settled by agreement between the parties it would eventually be heard and decided by a judge in a court. Litigation is one way that people and companies resolve disputes arising out of an infinite variety of factual circumstances. The formal case process begins upon the plaintiffs filing of a complaint to a particular judicial body or court. This document contains an explanation of the particular action or neglect, which the defendant has done, that causes harm to the plaintiff and why the defendant should be held liable for the resulting damages.In civil cases, the "plaintiff" is the party who brings the lawsuit and the "defendant" is the party who is being sued. Before a lawsuit is commenced, the injured party may be referred to as the "claimant." A civil action is started by filing a "pleading" called a "Complaint" with the court, which is then "served" on the defendant along with a "Summons." The defendant must then timely file a pleading called a "Defense." Depending upon the complexity of the lawsuit, other pleadings and parties may be added. The purpose of this pleadings stage is simply to determine the legal claims, defenses and other legal issues involved. The pleadings serve as a framework for later proceedings. At trial, the parties present evidence in support of their claims or defenses to a judge. Evidence is then presented. Each party may call witnesses or introduce documents and exhibits in support of its arguments. The plaintiff presents evidence first, then the defendant. Once all the evidence has been presented, the parties give their closing arguments. After closing arguments, the court may pronounce a judgment depending on the evidence presented by the parties and according to the law. Any party who feels that the court didnt give a right verdict has the right to appeal regarding appealable cases.This litigation process has a lot of disadvantages. As a result many business persons resort to an alternative dispute resolution mechanism.Alternative Dispute resolution mechanisms(ADR)Alternative dispute resolution (ADR) refers to any process designed to resolve disputes that does not involve going to court. There are a number of advantages of Alternative Dispute Resolution in general over litigation. These are:The following are the most known kind of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms. Negotiation In this process, the parties come together informally, with or without attorneys to represent them. In such an informal setting, the parties air their differences and try to reach a settlement or resolution without the involvement of independent third parties. Because no third parties are involved and because of the informal set-up, negotiation provides the simplest and swift opportunity of dispute disposition outside the court structure. It has to be noted here that the presence of an attorney to represent one or both of the parties dose not in any way imply the involvement of an independent third party. Attorneys, if any at all, get involved in the dispute by representative capacity stepping into the foot and taking the place of the party they represent and hence they are regarded as parties to the dispute. Even if a lawsuit has been initiated, the parties may continue to negotiate their differences at any time during the litigation process and settle their dispute. B) Mediation Mediation is usually a private, voluntary, and informal process where a party-selected neutral assistants to the disputants to reach a mutually acceptable agreement.  In some cases and jurisdictions like the family dispute the parties are required to attempt mediation before they can go to court.  During the mediation process there is a wide opportunity to present evidence and arguments and to explore the interests of the parties.  The mediator is not empowered to render a decision.  The mediator is not a judge or arbitrator.  The mediators role is to facilitate the conversation and dialogue between and among the parties to the dispute. The mediator acts as a third-party neutral. There are a variety of mediation styles of practice that a mediator can use.  A mediators style depends upon the nature of the conflict, its setting, the experience and resources of the disputants, and the background and training of the mediator.  C) ArbitrationArbitration is a procedure for settling disputes in which both the disputants usually agree to accept the decision of the arbitrator as legally binding. This means the parties cannot take court action, except to enforce the award if the judgment debtor refuses to discharge his obligation. Arbitration is sometimes used as a substitute for a court proceeding. The arbitrator, the person who hears and decides the dispute, is selected by the parties. Frequently, the arbitrator is an authority and experienced in the area in which the dispute arises. Unlike the case compromise, there is a decision to be given by the arbitrator. This decision, unless it gravelly violates one of the parties right, is like a court decision and the parties are bound by it. Usually family cases are resolved by arbitration. The parties submit their cases to an arbitrator or a group of arbitrators. The arbitrator, like a judge, weighs the evidence, applies the law, and renders a decision, which as stated earlier becomes a binding decision against the parties to it. Arbitration, like compromise and conciliation, is another practical alternative to the delay and expense of the court system. However, the arbitration is dependent on the parties' agreement to arbitrate rather than litigate the dispute through a court. If they decide to submit the dispute to binding arbitration, the court will refuse to entertain the matter. At most the court will review the work of the arbitrator for errors committed in rendering a decision.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *